Delving into the Pros and Cons of Entry-Level Wheel Bases: A Comparison review against their Competitors
Logitech G29 for PS4/PS5/PC
Logitech G920 for Xbox series X/S Xbox 0ne/PC
Logitech G29 shifter bundle
Logitech G920 shifter bundle
Pros of the Logitech G29/G920:
- Great Entry-Level Wheel: Ideal for beginners looking to dive into sim racing.
- Affordable Price: Provides excellent value for the cost.
- Optional Shifter: Some bundles include a shifter for added realism.
- Platform Compatibility: Compatible with multiple platforms, including PC, PlayStation, and Xbox.
- Customizable Buttons: Offers plenty of customizable buttons for extensive button mapping options.
- Versatile Mounting: Numerous mounting points for compatibility with wheel stands and sim rigs.
- Carpet Grip: Features a carpet grip under the pedals, allowing use on various surfaces.
- Built-In Table Clamps: Table clamps are included for secure mounting.
- Satisfying Paddle Feel: Mounted paddles provide a tactile and satisfying click feel.
Cons of the Logitech G29/G920:
- Plastic Construction: Largely constructed from plastic, which may give it a less premium appearance.
- Noise and Clipping: Helical gears can produce noise when force feedback is set too high, leading to clipping issues.
- Clunky Force Feedback: Some users find the force feedback to be clunky or notchy.
- Basic Pedals: The included pedals are considered basic and may not offer the best pedal feel.
- Shifter Quality: The shifter may feel cheaper compared to competitors.
Conclusion:
The Logitech G29/G920 presents a compelling option for those entering the world of sim racing on a budget. It offers an affordable price point and compatibility with multiple platforms. However, it’s essential to note that the largely plastic construction and basic pedals might give it a somewhat toy-like appearance and feel.
While it does have some drawbacks, such as noise and clunky force feedback, it still provides a decent introduction to sim racing. Ultimately, the G29/G920 can be an excellent starting point for beginners, but more serious sim racers may consider investing in a higher-end wheel and pedal set for a more immersive experience. I started my sim-racing journey on the Logitech G29, it was a worthwhile upgrade from a controller. I would highly recommend this to any beginner sim racer looking for their first wheelbase.
Thrustmaster T248 for PS4/PS5/PC
Thrustmaster T248 for Xbox series X/S Xbox one/ PC
Pros of the Thrustmaster T248:
- Hybrid Drive System: The Thrustmaster T248 features a hybrid drive system that combines belts and gears, delivering exceptional force feedback.
- Built-in Display: It comes equipped with a built-in display that provides valuable race telemetry data.
- Versatile Feedback Settings: Offers three in-built force feedback settings to cater to different gaming preferences.
- Premium Shifters: High-quality magnetic paddle shifters ensure precise and satisfying shifts during gameplay.
- Entry-Level Pedals: The T248 includes reasonable entry-level pedals, making it accessible to gamers of varying skill levels.
- Mounting Options: This wheel can be easily mounted to a rig or secured using a table clamp, ensuring stability during intense gaming sessions.
- Adequate Force Feedback: Despite being an entry-level wheel, it delivers a satisfactory level of force feedback for an immersive gaming experience.
Cons of the Thrustmaster T248:
- Comparative Premium Feel: The Thrustmaster T248 may not match the premium feel of competitors like the Logitech G923.
- Plastic Shifters: The inclusion of plastic shifters can give the wheel a less premium appearance and feel.
- Additional Shifter Requirement: To fully experience the 3-pedal set, a separate shifter is needed, which may add to the overall cost.
- Pedal Grip Issues: The pedal rubber feet may not provide sufficient grip when placed directly on the floor, potentially causing stability concerns.
Conclusion
The Thrustmaster T248 presents a balanced offering in the world of gaming wheels. Its hybrid drive system, built-in display, and versatile feedback settings contribute to a compelling gaming experience. However, it may not match the premium feel of certain competitors and requires an additional shifter for full functionality. While it provides entry-level pedals, users should be aware of potential grip issues when using them on the floor. In summary, the T248 is a suitable choice for gamers seeking a satisfying wheel with an array of features while being mindful of certain limitations.
Logitech G923 for the PS4/PS5/PC
Logitech G923 for the Xbox series X/S Xbox one/PC
Pros of the Logitech G923:
- Revised Looks: The G923 boasts revised aesthetics, making it more visually appealing.
- TrueForce Feature: The newly added TrueForce feature enhances the immersive experience, adding to the overall realism.
- Smoother Brake Pedal: The two-step brake pedal now offers a slightly smoother feel.
- Compatible with Existing Shifter: Utilizes the same shifter as its predecessors, allowing cost-effective upgrades for existing Logitech users.
- Solid Entry-Level Option: Remains a solid choice for entry-level sim racing.
- Competitive Price: Offers a competitive price point for those entering the world of sim racing.
Cons of the Logitech G923:
- Limited Upgrade: The G923 may not provide a significant upgrade from its predecessors.
- Unchanged Force Feedback: Shares the same force feedback output as the G29, which some users find notchy or clunky.
Conclusion:
For current Logitech G29/G920 owners, the G923 may not offer enough of an upgrade to justify the switch. The similarities in pedals and force feedback make it feel like more of the same. Although the added vibrations from the TrueForce feature enhance immersion, they might not be substantial enough to warrant an upgrade.
However, if you’re new to sim racing, the G923 serves as an excellent entry point. It features a modern appearance, along with subtle differences that improve upon its predecessors, making it a strong contender in the realm of entry-level steering wheels.
Pros of the Thrustmaster T300RS GT edition
- Force Feedback: The T-300 RS GT offers strong and precise force feedback from a dual belt system, providing a realistic driving experience.
- Compatibility: It is compatible with various gaming platforms, including PlayStation and PC, making it versatile for different gaming setups.
- Realistic Pedals: The set includes three pedals so a shifter can be easily introduced.
- Detachable Wheel: The GT-style detachable wheel allows for easy customization and compatibility with other Thrustmaster wheel rims.
- Easy Setup: The T-300 RS GT is relatively easy to set up, making it accessible for both beginners and experienced sim racers.
- Compatible with Thrustmaster TCLM Pedals: The T-300 RS GT is specifically designed to be compatible with Thrustmaster TCLM pedals, which are renowned for their high-quality construction
Cons of the Thrustmaster T300RS GT edition
- Price: Compared to entry-level racing wheels, the T-300 RS GT is relatively expensive, which may be a drawback for budget-conscious gamers.
- Compatibility with Older Games: While it’s compatible with many modern racing games, it may not work as seamlessly with older titles that lack support for this wheel.
- Plastic Build: Some users may find the plastic components on the wheel rim and pedals less premium compared to more expensive alternatives.
Conclusion
Overall, the Thrustmaster T-300 RS GT edition offers a good balance of performance and features for sim racing enthusiasts, but it may not be suitable for everyone due to its price and some limitations in terms of features and build quality.
Pros of the Thrustmaster T-GT 2:
- Detachable Wheel Rim: Allows for extensive customization options, letting you tailor your racing experience.
- Abundance of Buttons: Provides numerous buttons for in-game mapping, enhancing control and convenience.
- Dual Belt System: Utilizes a dual belt system, delivering maximum force feedback detail for an immersive experience.
- Top Non-Direct Drive Wheel: Considered one of the best non-direct drive wheels available, offering a high level of performance.
- Robust Ecosystem: Thrustmaster’s ecosystem caters to a wide range of sim racers’ needs.
Cons of the Thrustmaster T-GT 2:
- High Price: Comes with a hefty price tag for a non-direct drive wheel, potentially affecting its affordability for some users.
- Plastic Pedals: The largely plastic pedals may not match the overall quality of the bundle.
- Load Cell Upgrade Needed: To have a load cell pedal, you’ll need to upgrade to the T-LCM pedals separately.
- Lacks Shifter: There is no included shifter, which limits the potential of the three-pedal setup.
- Bulky Wheel Base: The wheelbase is bulky, which could obstruct vision when used on certain sim rigs.
- Intermediate Setup: Considered an intermediate-level setup, there are better options available in the market at a similar price point.
Conclusion:
While the Thrustmaster T-GT 2 offers some compelling features, including a detachable wheel rim and a robust ecosystem, it comes with a premium price for a non-direct drive wheel. The plastic pedals and the need for a separate load cell pedal upgrade might not align with its higher cost. Additionally, the lack of an included shifter and the bulky wheelbase could be limiting factors.
Ultimately, the T-GT 2 serves as an intermediate-level setup, and prospective buyers should carefully consider their priorities and preferences when evaluating it against other options available at a similar price point in the market.
Wrapping Up the Comparison Review: Making Informed Choices in the World of Gaming Wheels
In conclusion, when comparing the Logitech G29/G920 to the Thrustmaster T248, both present intriguing choices for sim racing enthusiasts. The Logitech G29/G920 offers an affordable entry point with cross-platform compatibility, although its plastic construction and basic pedals may not match the premium feel some users desire. On the other hand, the Thrustmaster T248 boasts a balanced feature set with a hybrid drive system and a built-in display, but it may lack the premium touch of other competitors and require additional investments for full functionality.
For existing Logitech G29/G920 owners, the Logitech G923 may not offer a significant upgrade, as it shares many similarities in pedals and force feedback. However, newcomers to sim racing will find the G923 to be a solid starting point with modern improvements.
In the realm of sim racing, the Thrustmaster T-300 RS GT edition strikes a good balance between performance and features, though it may not suit everyone due to its price and certain limitations.
Lastly, the Thrustmaster T-GT 2, while offering some impressive features, comes at a premium price for a non-direct drive wheel. Prospective buyers should weigh the cost against the plastic pedals, the need for upgrades, and the bulkiness of the wheelbase when considering it as an intermediate-level setup.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual preferences, priorities, and budget constraints, as each of these gaming wheels has its unique strengths and weaknesses.
Disclaimer: Please note that these are affiliate links, and I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you.